Zaytinya

We had such a pleasant time at Zaytinya. I was really excited to try their beautiful hummus, and the taste and the texture did not disappoint. The bread basket was surprisingly very satisfying. The bread looked like a cracker but it was in fact tender with the right proportion of crispiness. The octopus was cooked to perfection and we very much enjoyed the puree that it came with. I could go on and on about how much I am so contented with the meal and the coffee! The halloumi may not be to our liking, but well that should not be a reason to take any star out of this review. Will save Zaytinya in our to-go list for a special occasion.

- Yaninee Nachom -

Had such a beautiful and romantic dinner at Zaytinya in the city. The restaurant is absolutely stunning — cozy, aesthetic, and designed with a modern Middle Eastern touch that instantly sets the vibe. It’s warm, intimate, and perfect for a date or a special night out. We went with their Chef’s Experience, which is $80 per person (or $125 with wine pairing) and honestly, it’s so worth it. You get multiple courses — appetizers, salads, sides, entrées, and two desserts. Even though the portions are smaller, the variety and amount of food you get make it more than enough for two people. Plus, you get to try so many dishes you probably wouldn’t think to order individually. Everything was flavorful and beautifully presented. The spreads, salads, shrimp, falafel, and hot appetizers were amazing. I also tried a cocktail with za’atar, which was strong, unique, and really delicious. The service was friendly and very attentive, and the whole atmosphere felt elevated but still comfortable. It’s one of those restaurants you walk into and immediately feel relaxed. I would definitely come back to explore more of their menu. Highly recommend for anyone who loves Middle Eastern/Mediterranean flavors or wants a romantic, memorable dinner in the city.

- Roze -

Hit up Zaytinya for an earlier dinner on a Monday and the place was great. Started with the lamb hummus and another dip then on to the scallops and octopus and barely had room for the lamb burger but was still able to devour it because it was just that good. The service and ambiance were perfect as well. Would definitely go back to try other things.

- Stinson Parks III -

Went there for my birthday. Such a pleasant experience We opted to order A La Carte as you have the option to have the Chef's Experience. We loved the bread that was given warm, puffy and fragrant. Lamb hummus and alumni cheese for aptz were tasty. We shared the steak that was plenty for two, the veggies that accompanied it could have been a bit tastier. For desserts we had the kataifi that wasn't too sweet but balanced. We will definitely go back as drinks too were really good. The restaurant as also a great looking bar.

- michael t -

Must visit if you’re a fan of Mediterranean cuisine. Thoroughly enjoyed my birthday dinner here. I was committed to trying the NYC location after my DC experience and I was so impressed. Selection : Lamb Baharat, Brussels & Shish Tauk. Everything was delicious. The service went above and beyond— shoutout to Ricardo!Would definitely return.

- Annika D. -

Some of the best food I’ve ever had in my life. Went there with some friends and ordered the tasting menu, with an extra order of their lamb chops. We ate so much fresh bread (it kept coming out) with their delicious hummus, that we had to stop ourselves. Notably, this place had the best hummus, brussels sprouts, salad (smoked beet salata), and Greek yogurt I’ve ever had. I never thought I would say that about a salad, but the candied walnuts worked so well with their beets and cheese. By the end of the meal we were stuffed and extremely happy with the food we received. Definitely a great way to celebrate a milestone!

- Sebastian Ortega -

An amazing Mediterranean spot near Flatiron with a beautiful interior, great atmosphere, and excellent service. The food quality was top-notch — everything we ordered was flavorful and well-prepared. The scallop dish, in particular, stood out as the star of the meal. Portions were on the smaller side, so it felt a bit pricey for the amount of food, but the quality definitely made up for it. Perfect place if you’re looking for a refined, delicious meal in a great setting.

- Kentaro K -